Grupp: Huvudforum

Marknads Debatt USA

0
Ogilla!
10
Gilla!
2004-04-26 03:27:28

Aterger en marknads debatt med en kollega - han har bra points i sin argumentation - Jag är Mr A och vedeborande Mr B

*****************

----- Original Message -----
From: Mr A
Sent: Friday, April 23, 2004 12:22 PM
Subject: Impressive Durable Goods


Ex-transportation orders rose 3.3%, ex-defense 3.8% : non-defense capital goods shipments up 11% in Q1 (annualized) - On top of that, February got revised higher to 3.8% from 2.5%. Looks like Q1 GDP will reach somewhere around 5-5.5% -- Its also interesting that current charts are showing corporations having a positive financing gap (spread between investment and cash flow) for the first time in at least a half century.

This indicates that we should reasonably expect a pick up in capex going forward - thus, the economic growth is
likely to extend itself throughout the year at a reasonable rate, possibly at 4% or more. Questions is, how much
will current profits be off-set by an increase in hiring (health costs etc).

_________

From: Mr B

Sent: 4/23/04 12:36:33 PM
Subject: Re: Impressive Durable Goods


Actually, I think the real question is regarding P/E ratios.

Earnings are nice but bull markets are the result of expanding P/E ratio's more than expanding earnings.

From a technicians point of view: Its the behavior / the value the crowd places on a $1 of expected earnings, not the earnings that drives the market.

That said - given that P/E ratios tend to expand as interest rates decline and contract as interest rates rise; how long can a bull market last in an expanding interest rate environment?

________

From: Mr A

Sent: Friday, April 23, 2004 1:08 PM
Subject: Re: Impressive Durable Goods


From a fundamentalist / technician point of view ; what volume is to price action, is also what expansion in earnings
is to P/E ratio's - Indeed, historically P/E ratio's expand when rates fall and vice versa, but not always - at current juncture, real rates are close to the historic average of 2.75 - 3% (10Y minus deflator) - so, to off-set this level, earnings will have to expand (percent wise) more than P/E's (depending also on how we measure the P/e multiple)

From a technicians point of view - given the clear breadth in the market, as well as notable rotations, thus far, it stands reasonable to expect that the majority of participants have a favorable perception on $1 of expected earnings.

______

From: Mr B
Subject: Re: Impressive Durable Goods


P/E's have run inversely to interest rates (lock step) since 1959. Can you show that "real rates" matter more than nominal rates?

Even if the market participants have a favorable view of earnings growth, that does not always lead to a P/E expansion. Earnings grew in comfortable double digits from 1968 to 1982 but the P/E contracted preventing those earnings from resulting in a market price expansion. As a matter of fact, there were years where earnings expanded and the market contracted.

_______

From: Mr A

Sent: Friday, April 23, 2004 3:29 PM
Subject: Re: Impressive Durable Goods 

Real rates do matter for the bond market - the historic average is a factor for them when discounting inflation, and has always been; especially so during the bubble years, and even so during the 70's - Thus, if inflation proves to be where it is today, as in the coming months, then the 10Y would have less upside potential. Obviously, we have to consider what the expected inflation is, and how comfortable the Fed will be when stronger data on employment kicks in. But, generally speaking, the 3% level is a respected benchmark.

"....Even if the market participants have a favorable view of earnings growth, that does not always lead to a P/E expansion. Earnings grew in comfortable double digits from 1968 to 1982 but the P/E contracted preventing those earnings from resulting in a market price expansion. As a matter of fact, there were years where earnings expanded and the market contracted...."


I would probably not compare the period of misery during the 70's with today's environment - though "some" variables are inevitably similar - But prior to the 70's period, the market had already come from a supercharged era, and so any negative news during the seventies would be more sensitive than those with positive news. (Hence inflation, interest rates) - however, given the large decline since 2000, the appetite for equity risk has increased as the market sees sustainable (proven) economic growth with reasonable inflation. That said, market analysis purely based on P/E is hardly conclusive without considering other variables, such as geopolitical events, inflation, capex, debt etc - in this regard Mr B, I believe that price action will be the ultimate (classic) voting mechanism as we go forward. If price action shows solid rotation, as well as the ability (majority issues) to stay above the 200 DMA, then the market stands a good chance to expand its P/E.

_______

From: Mr B

Hi

I have attached two items that might interest you.
1 -The chart of P/E ratios compared to yields ( yields here are inversed for visual affect)
2 - Something I wrote a year ago regarding cycles in the P/E ratio

Where I don't believe you will agree with all of it, you might be interested in the P/E cycles illustration.
This is the main reason I do not believe that P/E's can expand significantly at this time. I hope you have the time to read it and comment.

I do believe that the market is far from resuming its bear trend. But nature may limit the upside. As a matter of fact your comment below "however, given the large decline since 2000, the appetite for equity risk has increased as the market sees sustainable (proven) economic growth with reasonable inflation." is a good argument supporting the secular bear thesis. After a true secular bear risk aversion would be the norm. The appetite for risk so soon after a sharp decline suggests more decline is needed to wash out the excess.

All the best,


________

From: Mr A


I looked at item 1 and briefly on item 2 - will continue on 2 during the week.

I should highlight that P/E's do not need to expand for the market go up, provided that earnings will be so good that the ratio itself moves horizontally - in this regard, history supports this type of market. For instance, in item 1, we can clearly observe what fast growing earnings did to the P/E ratio between 1958 - 1969. Essentially, the P/E was fluctuating between 19 and 16 for many years as the market rose 126% (Dow monthly) over the same period. Meanwhile, interest rates went from 4% to approximately 7.70%, or plus 370 Bps - The reason? Inflation rose and forced rates higher. So, why did the market advance in midst of higher rates and inflation? A simple answer might be that investor?s favored strong growth in earnings while the P/E ratio moved sideways. It can be argued that we are about to experience a similar type of market since we have had strong results with upward revisions (Q2), yet the market is discounting a sideways move to compress P/E's.


"....But nature may limit the upside...."

Indeed - we will never know for sure until it actually happens - however, a short-term sideways trade is in my opinion a wining position given that earnings will further compress P/E ratio's, and that rotational breadth continues to be a favorable action for the market. The last week or so have proved just that, as funds flow away from techs into defensive plays, only to flow back to techs again. At this point, I'm not discounting any sudden geopolitical events, like a spike in oil prices, or war related activities.


"..... a good argument supporting the secular bear thesis. The appetite for risk so soon after a sharp decline suggests more decline is needed to wash out the excess....."

Your rationale is logical - though, it's important to also remember that the market (SP 500) consolidated or "bottomed" for almost 11 months prior to this advance. The time in this regard allowed the market an opportunity to really sort things out. Most of all, it allowed confidence to build among buyers - Of course, nothing is 100%, but the case for additional decline (undefined by you) would in my judgment be limited as of yet. In addition, we are now faced with very good macro-economic numbers ahead of us. Corporate cash flow is basically booming as the financing gap (spread between CF and investment) has turned positive for the first time in at least a half century. Inventory levels remain at historically low levels, and employment activity "seems" to finally have picked up. The key will be how well the equity market adjusts to rising rates due to inflation "scare".

I'm also a firm believer to the principle of ever changing trends - an increased appetite for risk after a long sharp decline, may not prove to be a speculative behavior, but merely an increased confidence in the economy as a whole - hopefully not to the same extreme as witnessed during the late nineties.

Regards, 



Inlägget är redigerat av författaren.

Upp till toppen
Kommentera

 

Tjäna mer pengar på dina aktieaffärer

Bli medlem på Aktieguiden gratis på 30 sekunder.

Som medlem på Aktieguiden kan du:

  • Läsa träffsäkra tips och analyser från duktiga traders
  • Ställa frågor till och chatta med aktieproffs
  • Få gratis tillgång till en över miljon inlägg aktiehandel
  • Skapa egna privata forumgrupper

För att få delta i diskussionerna på Aktieguiden krävs att du verifierar ditt mobilnummer. Läs gärna mer om varför verifiering behövs.

 

Redan medlem? Klicka här för att logga in.